Most defense teams prepare for a plaintiff’s expert by reading the report. That’s a start. It isn’t preparation.
An expert’s report tells you what they plan to say in this case. Their prior testimony tells you what they have said in every case before it: under oath, on the record, often with a camera running. The gap between the two is where cross-examination lives.
The strongest defense doesn’t wait for the deposition to learn who the expert is. It walks in already knowing. Here are four ways to make an expert’s history work for your client.
1. Compare the standard, not just the conclusion. Experts rarely contradict their bottom line. They drift on the standard behind it. A nursing expert who calls a strict two-hour turning schedule the bare minimum in your case may have told another jury that repositioning must be individualized to each resident. Both can’t be the universal standard of care. Find the version they gave when it helped the other side.
2. Look for the template. Some experts reach the same conclusion no matter the facts. Every pressure injury was avoidable. Every fall was foreseeable. Every delay changed the outcome. When the same opinion appears across cases with different residents, different diagnoses and different facilities, jurors deserve to know. An opinion that never changes isn’t analysis. It’s a script.
3. Watch the video, not just the transcript. A transcript records the words. Video records the pause before the answer, the shift in tone when a chart entry comes out, the moment the expert stops making eye contact. Those cues shape your sequence and tell you which concessions to press. They also show you how this witness will come across to a jury, before your client pays to find out.
4. Turn their record into your theme. Prior testimony isn’t a gotcha. It’s evidence for your story. If your theme is “Care, Not Perfection,” the expert who once agreed that a skilled nursing team can do everything right and still see a wound develop has already made your point. Let their words frame the standard. Then let your experts, and your client’s documentation, show it was met.
None of this works if the record sits in one lawyer’s files. Defense teams face the same experts again and again, across firms and across states. The teams that share what they learn walk into the deposition with years of context. The teams that don’t start from scratch.
An expert can change their opinion. They can’t change their record.
Are you looking for more insights that might help you win your next case? Subscribe to the Second Chair Briefing and receive a monthly newsletter with healthcare defense strategies, upcoming events, and more.


